30 Comments
User's avatar
Sera's avatar

Well said. I think that Murray’s function is to be so obnoxiously boneheaded that slightly less boneheaded people look reasonable next to him. That’s a tough job, and he’s a natural.

PDP's avatar

It's astonishing that this halfwit gets publshed. I guess those who publish him have smoked the same hopium. After all this time, and so many American overseas 'adventures' you'd think the penny might have dropped: you're just not very good at war, chaps. Frankly, you're a bit shit at everything else. Stay at home for a bit and kill each other. Ho Chi Minh City sends its regards

Roshan Pedder's avatar

“Any people anywhere who desire to overthrow a dictatorship to have genuine representative governance will find us on their side.”

The chutzpah, the total distortion of reality is truly unbelievable. Here is only a very partial list of US interventions to overthrow democratically elected governments and install their favourite puppet dictator : Mosadeq in Iran 1953, replaced with the Shah. Guatemala 1954 Arbenz was overthrown to protect the rights of the United Fruit Company. Congo 1960 - the murder of Patrice Lumumba and the installation of Mobutu - one of the greatest ever tyrants in recent history. Brazil 1964- overthrow of another democratically elected government and another long term dictatorship. Chile 1973 overthrow of Allende and the helpful installation of General Pinochet.........

Sarah Roberts's avatar

Douglas Murray leans into the veneer of a polished English gentleman. This is thin disguise for the sneering contempt he manifests. Directed in rounded vowels towards those who dare have concern and compassion for the Palestinians suffering genocide and ethnic cleansing at the hands of Israel. Treating those who have a moral compass as somehow deluded, he preens and smirks as he pretends that his blousy pronouncements somehow amount to scholarship. He roundly deserves to be called out.

Dave's avatar

Someone who flip flops on opinions like that has no core principles. He is the definition of a grifter. His words are meaningless other than to allow people to nod along due to their own malignant philosophy and under-informed opinions. The concept of introspection clearly means nothing to him and the people who support him.

Great piece. He's infuriated me everytime I've seen him interviewed, but it can be difficult to clearly say 'you are wrong ' based on a single interview - geopolitics being so complex and nuanced as it is. All of it laid out bare like this really highlights how right being infuriated with him is.

Mo's avatar

Well said, Owen. Murray is a bit of a dimwit.

Mina's avatar

Job well done Owen.

The Custodian ✊✊🏻✊🏽✊🏿🍉💪🏽's avatar

Note 2: The Charlatan’s Calculus: Douglas Murray and the Death of Proportion

​Douglas Murray demands absolute empirical rigour from everyone else, sneering at progressives, Muslims, and journalists for uncritically swallowing convenient narratives. He presents himself as an apostle of cold, hard Enlightenment rationality. And yet, when the moment suits his political agenda, that lofty intellectual discipline vanishes like smoke.

​Consider his breathless amplification of atrocity claims following the 7 October attacks. Murray publicly and unequivocally claimed that infants had been beheaded, asserting this specific horror as an established, indisputable fact to preemptively obliterate any debate regarding moral or military restraint. The plain truth, however, is that his claim was false: subsequent forensic investigations, independent journalistic reviews, and official statements from the Israeli military confirmed that the story of beheaded babies was unverified and untrue. Did the grand champion of truth step back to acknowledge his falsehood or offer a shred of intellectual accountability? Of course not. As G.K. Chesterton dryly observed in The Man Who Knew Too Much (1922), ‘Modern intelligence won’t accept anything on authority. But it will accept anything without authority.’ The lie was simply too useful to be sacrificed to the inconvenient reality of facts.

​His handling of international law is equally dishonest. When confronted with the principle of proportionality, Murray avoided serious legal debate entirely. Instead, he deployed a deliberately absurd caricature, suggesting with grotesque theatricality that a ‘proportionate response’ would require Israel to decapitate the exact same number of infants and commit the exact same number of rapes in return.

​It is a trick as cheap as it is cynical. Murray knows perfectly well that international law does not define proportionality as a barbaric game of tit-for-tat revenge; it governs the permissible ratio between a specific military objective and anticipated civilian casualties. But engaging with actual law requires intellectual labour. It is far easier, and far more profitable for a media polemicist, to erect a grotesque straw man, knock it down with performative indignation, and declare victory before an adoring audience.

​If you claim the mantle of the uncompromising truth-teller, you must submit your own rhetoric to the same acid test you apply to others. When you trade in unverified atrocity tales, peddle outright falsehoods about beheaded infants, and retreat into dishonest debater’s tricks the moment your worldview is challenged, you are not a courageous defender of Western reason. You are merely a partisan with a polished accent—a charlatan pretending to hold the scales of ultimate truth while possessing neither the evidence, the consistency, nor the honesty to back it up.

NIZAMIXIII's avatar

I shall store your comments to be used as footnotes to my assertion that Murray is an utter c**t.

The Custodian ✊✊🏻✊🏽✊🏿🍉💪🏽's avatar

Note 1: The Inquisitor Without a God: Douglas Murray’s Hollow Pulpit

Douglas Murray’s public persona is a carefully choreographed pose: the unflinching defender of Western civilization, preening in a tailored suit as he lectures the masses on the decay of intellectual rigour. He performs the role of the lonely truth-teller with exquisite theatricality. Yet beneath the polished cadence lies a performance so glaringly hypocritical it borders on farce.

For a man who has made a lucrative career out of exposing the double standards of his opponents, Murray demonstrates a breathtaking immunity to self-examination. He harbours a particular disdain for traditional Islamic scholars—the so-called ‘Mullahs’—castigating them for their unbending dogma and absolute moral claims. Yet Murray himself speaks with an ironclad certainty that far outstrips the very scholars he despises. He broadcasts his pronouncements with overbearing confidence, yet that confidence is entirely hollow, devoid of any genuine metaphysical foundation.

Here lies the primary absurdity of his posture: he has no ontological basis whatsoever for the morality he so aggressively preaches. An atheist who conveniently styles himself a ‘cultural Christian’ whenever it suits his narrative, Murray selectively wraps himself in the holy cloak of Western heritage to lecture the world on civilizational duty, moral order, and absolute good and evil from a pulpit built out of thin air.

He arrogates to himself the authority of traditional Christian morality as a cudgel against Islam and the left, yet conveniently ignores the foundational tenets and divine commands of that very faith when examining his own life. Without divine revelation, objective transcendent truth, or a coherent ontological foundation, his moralizing is nothing more than personal preference masquerading as civilizational virtue. He demands the grandiosity of a Christian moral inquisitor while possessing neither divine authority nor personal allegiance to the tradition he selectively weaponizes.

Part 2 in the comments.

Tamsin brown's avatar

Maybe Sam Harris, who is similarly pompous, similarly bigoted and appears similarly spectacularly ill-informed.

NIZAMIXIII's avatar

With you on that one too!

Tamsin brown's avatar

I don’t think I loathe anyone more than I loathe Douglas Murray.

NIZAMIXIII's avatar

With you on this one. I sometimes stress myself wondering what I would do if I saw him in the street.

Neil McRae's avatar

I always visualise him in SS uniform; he's a pantomine figure really, 40 or 50 years ago he and his views would have been laughed out of court but nowadays he seems to have an audience who follow him for various reasons, probably being hard-of-thinking is one of them.

NIZAMIXIII's avatar

He’s like Rees Mogg in that regard. Playing the aristo, posh voice and oxbridge. Yes milord. No milord. Three bags full milord.

sean mellerick's avatar

The opinions of these cheerleaders of war have been proven wrong time and again, and I’m constantly disappointed that these pieces never mention the human cost that their flag-waving, jingoistic, bullshit supports. They don’t care that the country's youth and future are sent to their deaths or to be physically or mentally mutilated. They don’t care that innocent people men, women, and children, in the country that is this year's chosen distraction from politicians' political troubles. Something is wrong when young people are sent into a physical and mental meat grinder on a politician’s whim or to boost chances of re-election. As history has shown us.

Doug Tarnopol's avatar

People like Murray are not paid to be right. They’re paid to manufacture consent for their owners. That anyone falls for it is on them.

NIZAMIXIII's avatar

Murray’s is top of my list of faces to be printed on novelty bum paper.